10. “Platonic” Season 2
For years, I fretted over getting my Top 10 lists “right.” There I was, every December, arguing with coworkers and arguing with myself while striving to pinpoint the objective rationales that would unlock the perfect sequence of the year’s best shows.
Criticism, of course, is as subjective as the art it’s assessing (because, I would argue, criticism is also art — when done correctly, hehe). But looking back on those first few years, I wasn’t wasting time. (My colleagues may disagree. Sorry, guys.) But interrogating your own opinions is as essential to personal growth as accepting the bias inherent to your individualism. Thinking less is rarely the right way to go when confronted with a task worth taking seriously, and these lists — even if only because they tend to be quite widely read — are worth at least that.
I know some critics hate making them. I love it. Even today, when I’ve already written many thousands of words about many dozens of shows and episodes, I didn’t punt on this blurb. I still see my Top 10 lists as a chance to celebrate series that deserve the extra attention; that fought to be the best story they could be; that unlocked something unique, moving, and powerful.
This list may not be “right” — meaning, if I redid the list in a month, the order would likely change and a few picks might get swapped in for a few outliers — but these are still the right shows. They’re true. They’re good. They’re valid.
Especially “Platonic.” Don’t take my long-winded rambling as justification for including a comedy about two best friends who hang out at a bar, take too many drugs, and generally use each other to avoid their greater responsibilities. Francesca Delbanco and Nicholas Stoller’s non-rom-com is one of the great modern sitcoms: trusting its two towering leads to carry the load, while infusing quiet profundity into their outlandish adventures. You should watch it. I’ve watched it more times than I care to admit. And I’ll probably watch some more as soon as I’m done with this next sentence. Because if these aren’t reasons enough to make this list “right,” then I’m finally happy to be wrong. —BT

















